News Summary
Liz Magill has stepped down as president of the University of Pennsylvania following backlash from her congressional testimony on antisemitism in colleges. Despite an apology, her remarks sparked outrage, leading to her resignation effective December 8, 2023. The situation highlighted divisions within the university regarding the handling of antisemitism issues. Magill served in her role for approximately 17 months and will transition to a visiting professor position at the London School of Economics, among other roles.
Philadelphia – Liz Magill has resigned from her position as president of the University of Pennsylvania following significant controversy stemming from her recent congressional testimony regarding antisemitism on college campuses. Magill, who took office in July 2022, announced her departure effective December 8, 2023, just three days after she faced tough scrutiny during a House Committee hearing led by Republican Chair Virginia Foxx.
The hearing, which took place on December 5, was convened to address what Foxx described as a rise in “vitriolic hate-filled antisemitism” at educational institutions. Magill joined other university leaders, including Claudine Gay from Harvard and Sally Kornbluth from MIT, to discuss the growing concerns surrounding antisemitism in academic environments. In her opening statement, Magill condemned the actions of Hamas, a response that was, at the time, seen as well received by the committee.
However, the atmosphere shifted dramatically when the contentious nature of questions began to emerge. During the hearing, Representative Elise Stefanik pressed Magill on whether calls for the genocide of Jews would violate the university’s code of conduct. Her subsequent reply, which indicated that such determinations would be “context-dependent,” prompted a swift and widespread backlash, leading to public outrage across various platforms.
Following the testimony, Magill expressed regret over her response, acknowledging that it not only harmed the public’s perception of the university but also contradicted her personal values. This realization came amid mounting criticism and chaos within the university itself, where shareholders and alumni alike began demanding her resignation, with billionaire donor Marc Rowan leading the charge. Public anger was reflected in thousands of messages directed at Magill, including threats and billboards labeling her antisemitic.
In a bid to address the fallout, Magill released an apology video where she recognized the severity of the issue regarding the demand for genocide and the implications of her earlier remarks. Despite her efforts, turmoil ensued within the university board, revealing a significant divide over her leadership and approach to the antisemitism crisis.
Ultimately, on December 8, 2023, Magill made the decision to resign, describing the situation surrounding her position as “utterly untenable.” This marked a swift conclusion to her presidency, making her tenure one of the shortest in the history of the university, lasting approximately 17 months. At the time of her resignation, she was compensated with a total package of roughly $2.3 million, which included a base salary of $1.48 million and a performance bonus of $725,000.
Scott Bok, the chair of the university’s board, also resigned his position following Magill’s departure, stating that the atmosphere surrounding her leadership had devolved into a chaotic culture war. Despite the polarizing atmosphere, Magill remains a tenured professor at Penn and has transitioned to a visiting law professor role at the London School of Economics, as well as taking a senior fellow position at Harvard Law School.
In the wake of the controversy, Magill continues to attract a mix of support and criticism for her handling of antisemitism issues, highlighting an ongoing dialogue about the responsibilities of university leaders in addressing hate and bias on campus. As the university navigates through this turbulent period, the impact of this controversy will likely resonate within the academic community for some time.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Former University of Pennsylvania President Regrets Testimony on Antisemitism
Scott L. Bok Resigns as Chair of University of Pennsylvania Trustees
University of Pennsylvania Faces Antisemitism Power Struggle
University Leaders Urged to Uphold Independence Amid Pressure
University of Pennsylvania Faces Scrutiny Over Donations
Additional Resources
- Politico: Liz Magill’s Departure
- Wikipedia: Antisemitism
- Inquirer: Magill’s Salary and Bonus
- Google Search: Liz Magill
- Chronicle: Fallout at Penn
- Encyclopedia Britannica: University of Pennsylvania
- Fox Business: Harvard Hires Magill
- Google News: Antisemitism in Universities
