New York City Unveils Ranking of America’s Leading Doctors

New York City, July 31, 2025

News Summary

New York City has released a comprehensive ranking of over 2,800 top doctors across 15 medical specialties, based on performance data, peer recommendations, and quality assessments. This ranking provides valuable insights for patients to make informed healthcare decisions. Each specialty features a top-ranked list, highlighting the capabilities of specialists in various fields. The methodology emphasizes accountability and quality in medical practice, marking a significant shift in how patients can assess their healthcare providers.

New York City Releases Comprehensive Ranking of America’s Leading Doctors for 2025

New York City, NY – A new comprehensive ranking of America’s top doctors for 2025 has been released, featuring over 2,800 physicians from 15 medical specialties, according to reports from Newsweek and Statista. This marks the first exhaustive publication of its kind, following earlier rankings that focused exclusively on vascular and spine surgeons. The rankings aim to give patients data-driven insights to make informed health care decisions.

The list includes 175 to 200 doctors within each medical specialty, with the top 30 in each category ranked numerically while the others are presented in alphabetical order. The rankings are based on a combination of performance data, peer recommendations, quality assessments, and certifications, allowing prospective patients to gauge the capabilities and expertise of various specialists.

Ranking Methodology and Evaluation

Doctors featured in the rankings can be affiliated with up to three hospitals, which are determined based on patient volume and thorough desk research. Those not associated with hospitals may operate in private practices or specialized institutes. A career in medicine requires extensive training, dedication, and an acknowledgment of the demanding nature of the profession.

Key factors in the evaluation process include:

• Performance data, which accounts for 60% of the rankings and relies on Medicare Fee-for-Service claims and CareJourney insights into treatment episodes, mortality rates, unplanned readmissions, and payment averages.
• Peer recommendations, which make up 27.5% of the scoring, were collected through an extensive online survey of thousands of medical experts nationwide.
• Quality assessment, which contributed 7.5% to the final scores, and various certifications, making up the remaining 5%.

Doctors treating a high volume of patients received “High Performance” marks, signified by ribbons in the rankings.

Top-ranked Specialists

Among the notable entries, Dr. Leonard Girardi from NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Medical Center was recognized as the leading cardiothoracic surgeon. His expertise highlights the importance of passion and commitment in delivering patient-centered care.

Dr. Joseph Ricotta, ranked number two in vascular surgery, pointed out advancements in minimally invasive procedures and artificial intelligence tools that enhance treatment effectiveness. Additionally, Dr. Martin Weiser emerged as the top colorectal surgeon, advocating for personalized care for young patients battling colorectal cancer and focusing on improving long-term quality of life.

The emphasis on community service and transparency in patient care is a crucial aspect stressed among specialists. The ranking methodology took into account the evolving nature of medical practices and the introduction of new technologies that improve patient outcomes.

Background Context

This ranking serves as a critical resource for patients navigating a complex health care landscape. As medical specialties continue to evolve and adapt to new technologies and treatment protocols, data-driven rankings empower patients in making informed decisions regarding their health care providers. The evaluation process represents a significant shift toward accountability and quality in the medical profession.

FAQ

What is the purpose of the ranking?

The ranking aims to provide patients with reliable, data-driven guidance to aid their health care decisions.

How many doctors are included in the ranking?

Over 2,800 doctors from 15 medical specialties are featured in the comprehensive ranking for 2025.

How were the doctors evaluated?

Doctors were assessed through performance data, peer recommendations, quality assessments, and certifications, with a weighted scoring system.

What factors contribute to a doctor’s ranking?

Doctor performance, peer recommendations, quality assessments, and certifications all contribute to the overall ranking.

What specialties are represented in the ranking?

The ranking covers 15 different medical specialties, providing a broad overview of leading doctors across various fields.

Key Features of the Ranking

Feature	Description
Number of Doctors	Over 2,800 doctors from 15 specialties
Evaluation Methods	Performance data, peer recommendations, quality assessments, certifications
Ranking Distribution	Top 30 ranked numerically, others listed alphabetically
Performance Data Sources	Medicare Fee-for-Service claims, CareJourney insights
Weighting Factors	Performance (60%), Peer recommendations (27.5%), Quality assessment (7.5%), Certifications (5%)

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

HHS Secretary Dismisses Vaccine Advisory Panel
Philadelphia’s Revolutionary CRISPR Gene-Editing Therapy Saves Infant
Philadelphia’s Top Doctors Revealed for 2023

Additional Resources

• Finger Lakes1: New York Healthcare 2025
• Wikipedia: Healthcare in the United States
• Star Gazette: Guthrie Clinic Ranking
• Google Search: Best healthcare workplaces 2025
• Politico: New York’s Healthcare Spending
• Google Scholar: Healthcare spending New York
• LoHud: New York Healthcare Costs
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Healthcare in New York
• Hudson Valley Post: New York Healthcare Study
• Google News: New York healthcare state ranking