News Summary
The Philadelphia School District is embroiled in a federal investigation concerning its asbestos management practices. A proposed agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice has been delayed amid health concerns about numerous school buildings containing asbestos. The district is under scrutiny for failing to comply with federal inspection regulations, affecting over 300 facilities. While facing these challenges, the Philadelphia area continues to show educational success, with multiple districts ranked highly in recent evaluations.
Philadelphia – The Philadelphia School District is currently embroiled in a significant federal investigation regarding its management of asbestos in school buildings, leading to a delay in a proposed agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ). This agreement, which was scheduled to be considered at a school board meeting on May 29, 2025, was postponed as the DOJ was reportedly unprepared to move forward with the discussions, resulting in no vote being taken during the session.
Superintendent Dr. Tony Watlington was set to address the board prior to the anticipated vote, highlighting the urgent nature of the topic. Despite the scheduled vote being pulled from the agenda, a district spokeswoman indicated that the DOJ may require additional review before any further steps can be taken.
The investigation into the district’s asbestos management practices comes as the Philadelphia School District faces mounting health concerns related to environmental safety. Numerous buildings within the district are reported to contain asbestos, and some have been closed due to hazardous conditions. The district has not complied with federal requirements for inspecting its buildings for asbestos, with over 300 of its facilities potentially housing the harmful material. Under federal law, inspections must occur every three years, with more frequent assessments mandated in the presence of asbestos.
Education District Rankings
While the Philadelphia School District grapples with these critical health and safety issues, the region has seen success in other educational arenas. The Pittsburgh Business Times recently released its 2025 School Guide, ranking public school districts based on their performance in PSSA and Keystone Exams over the past three years. Southwestern Pennsylvania school districts excelled in this evaluation, with several districts from the Philadelphia area making it to the top 10.
For the second consecutive year, the Fox Chapel Area School District in Allegheny County has maintained the top position in the rankings. The Upper St. Clair School District secured second place, followed by Lower Merion School District, which is notable for being the alma mater of basketball legend Kobe Bryant, in third place. Rounding out the top five are the Radnor Township School District in Delaware County and Peters Township School District in Washington County.
Philadelphia Area Districts in Rankings
Other Philadelphia area districts that appear in the top 25 include Springfield (14th), New Hope-Solebury (15th), Haverford Township (16th), Wallingford-Swarthmore (17th), Colonial (22nd), Rose Tree Media (24th), and Wissahickon, which ranks 25th. Significantly, Allegheny County has produced the highest number of districts in the top 10 compared to any other county.
Continued Environmental Concerns
As the Philadelphia School District continues to navigate the DOJ investigation and its implications, environmental concerns regarding asbestos management persist. The district has faced scrutiny over its lack of compliance with inspection regulations and has accrued a backlog of maintenance issues that endanger health and safety within the schools. The fiscal impact has also been considerable, with millions spent on inspections and remediation to address the environmental risks posed by asbestos.
The decision to delay the agreement with the DOJ is a critical moment for the Philadelphia School District as it attempts to resolve its longstanding issues with asbestos and improve conditions in its schools. While the district has experienced setbacks in meeting federal standards, the ongoing performance of its educational facilities in other rankings illustrates a contrasting narrative of success amidst challenges.
The complete list of school rankings can be accessed on BizJournals.com.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- NBC Philadelphia: Asbestos Investigation
- Inquirer: Philadelphia Asbestos Investigation
- CBS News: Top Schools in Pennsylvania
- Billy Penn: Philly School District Successes and Struggles
- Metro Philadelphia: Board of Education Asbestos Agreement
- Wikipedia: Asbestos
- Google Search: Philadelphia School District asbestos
- Google Scholar: Philadelphia school asbestos investigation
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Asbestos
- Google News: Philadelphia school district asbestos
