Categories: Pennsylvania Business NewsPennsylvania News

Pennsylvania’s Tax Burden: Challenges for Small Businesses

High tax rates are leading to increased challenges for small businesses in Pennsylvania.

News Summary

A recent report reveals Pennsylvania as one of the least tax-friendly states for small businesses, with a corporate tax rate exceeding 29.4%. This high rate poses significant challenges for small business growth and sustainability when compared to states with zero corporate tax. The Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry advocates for an extension of tax cuts while Governor Josh Shapiro proposes a reduction in the corporate net income tax, highlighting the ongoing debate over tax reform in the state.

Pennsylvania has been ranked as one of the least tax-friendly states for small businesses, according to a report by BusinessFinancing.co.uk. The state has a corporate tax rate averaging over 29.4 percent, which places it among the highest in the nation and raises concerns for small business growth and economic competitiveness.

The study evaluated the tax environments across all 50 states, utilizing data from Deloitte and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) to determine small business tax-friendliness. With Pennsylvania’s considerable corporate tax burden, small business owners may find it increasingly difficult to thrive, especially compared to states with zero corporate tax.

States like South Dakota, Wyoming, Nevada, Ohio, Texas, and Washington offer a more conducive environment for small businesses as they rely on local gross receipts taxes instead of a corporate tax. In comparison, the corporate tax rate in Pennsylvania can significantly hamper a small business’s bottom line.

Data from the report indicates that Minnesota, which has the highest corporate tax rate in the U.S., combines a 21 percent federal rate with a 9.8 percent state rate. This results in a total tax obligation of approximately $30,800 for profits of $100,000. Such figures emphasize the challenges faced by small business owners in states with high tax rates.

The report raises questions about the impact of corporate taxes on the sustainability of small businesses. Many larger corporations often take advantage of legal loopholes that allow them to reduce their tax liabilities, leaving smaller enterprises to shoulder a disproportionate tax burden that can hinder their ability to compete effectively.

In a related effort, the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry is lobbying for Congress to extend small business tax cuts introduced in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. These tax cuts included a reduction of the federal corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 21 percent and a 20 percent deduction for qualified business income for pass-through entities. The cuts are scheduled to expire soon, prompting concerns about the potential negative impact on small businesses in Pennsylvania.

Additionally, Governor Josh Shapiro has proposed a budget that aims to accelerate the reduction of Pennsylvania’s corporate net income tax (CNIT) from its current rate of 7.99 percent to 4.99 percent by 2029 instead of the previously projected date of 2031. This proposition comes as part of a broader strategy to enhance Pennsylvania’s competitive edge against neighboring states.

Part of the proposed changes includes an overhaul of the tax system to simplify tax reporting processes and to implement combined reporting for corporations. This would mean that all profits from subsidiaries need to be reported collectively. However, critics argue that combined reporting could complicate tax filings and business operations within the state, potentially leading to unintended consequences for small business owners.

Pennsylvania’s historical tax structures have often led to missed opportunities for corporate investments and economic developments. Previous attempts by legislative Republicans to fast-track corporate tax rate reductions have met with roadblocks, echoing the ongoing struggle for tax reform that aligns with the needs of smaller enterprises.

The chamber estimates that failing to renew the tax cuts could lead to an average tax increase of over $2,300 for taxpayers each year. Such financial pressure underscores the importance of efficient tax policy toward fostering economic growth and attracting new businesses to Pennsylvania.