Categories: College University AthleticsCollege/University NewsEducation

University of Pennsylvania Revises Swimming Records Amid Controversy

Female swimmers showing strength and determination during a competition.

News Summary

The University of Pennsylvania has revised swimming records held by Lia Thomas, a transgender athlete, and will apologize to female athletes who felt disadvantaged. Following a federal investigation, Penn will restore titles to the female competitors who lost to Thomas and will adopt ‘biology-based’ definitions for gender in athletics. This decision has sparked discussions over the fairness of transgender participation in women’s sports, highlighting the ongoing debate around gender identity in athletics.

Philadelphia – The University of Pennsylvania has modified three swimming records held by transgender athlete Lia Thomas and will issue formal apologies to female athletes who felt disadvantaged by her participation on the women’s swimming team. This action is part of an agreement reached in the wake of a federal civil rights investigation conducted by the U.S. Education Department, which found that Penn violated Title IX by permitting a transgender athlete to compete against cisgender women.

Under the terms of the agreement, the university will restore all individual Division I records and titles to female competitors who lost to Thomas during her time on the women’s team. Additionally, personalized apology letters will be sent to the affected female swimmers, acknowledging their concerns and experiences of inequity.

In 2022, Lia Thomas made history as the first openly transgender athlete to clinch an NCAA Division I title, winning the women’s 500-yard freestyle. Her participation spurred debates over fair competition and the implications of gender identity in sports. Following the resolution, Penn’s official records have been updated to indicate that the accomplishments attributed to Thomas during the 2021-22 season were achieved under eligibility rules that were in place at that time.

President J. Larry Jameson of Penn recognized that while the university adhered to NCAA eligibility standards, the competition faced by some student-athletes was not equitable, leading to feelings of anxiety and disadvantage among female swimmers. As a result of the settlement, Penn will implement “biology-based” definitions of male and female in its athletic programs, ensuring that males are barred from competing in women’s events.

Education Secretary Linda McMahon hailed the agreement as a milestone for women and girls in athletics, underscoring a restoration of women’s rights in competitive sports. The settlement arrives amidst a backdrop of initiatives from the previous Trump administration, which sought to limit the participation of transgender athletes in women’s categories and was followed by the Education Department temporarily withholding $175 million in federal funding from Penn.

Prior to the settlement, the Education Department had called upon the NCAA and various high school athletic associations to reclaim titles, awards, and records that were claimed to have been incorrectly granted due to the participation of transgender athletes. Although a 2017 study found no consistent evidence that transgender individuals possess an inherent advantage over their cisgender counterparts in sports, the conversation around the competitive advantages and implications of transgender participation remains a point of contention.

Following the adjustments, Thomas’s records have been removed from the University of Pennsylvania’s historical lists, with acknowledgments indicating her participation was in line with existing eligibility rules. The Education Department’s findings pointed to the conditions under which the university allowed male athletes to compete in women’s intercollegiate athletics and access women-only facilities, highlighting the complexities involved in these situations.

Before transitioning, Lia Thomas was a member of Penn’s men’s swimming team and began competing on the women’s team after undergoing testosterone suppression and assuming her female identity. The recent agreement will require Penn to publicly disclose its new policies related to transgender participation in athletics and their future implications for female competitors.

Former athletes have expressed appreciation for the resolution, sharing their perceptions of competing against Thomas as problematic from a fairness perspective. The discussions on athletic advantages for transgender individuals continue to evoke a range of opinions, with some studies suggesting that gender-affirming treatments can mitigate performance disparities.

This settlement indicates a notable shift towards biologically based classifications in athletics and contributes to the larger national discourse over transgender rights in the realm of sports.